Most weak marketing shortlists are the hiring manager's fault, not the recruiter's. A vague brief produces a vague shortlist, and no marketing recruitment agency in the UK can fix that by working harder. This guide is for hiring managers and in-house talent teams who want the first batch of CVs to be relevant. By the end you'll have a scoped role, a short list of genuine requirements, and a briefing conversation that earns the right candidates.
My argument is simple: write the brief for the person who'll do the job, then hand it to the person who'll find them. Not the other way round.
1. Scope the problem before you scope the role
Write down what's broken. Not the job title, the problem. "Our paid social spend has doubled and nobody owns the reporting" is a brief. "We need a Digital Marketing Manager" is a label that could mean four different jobs.
I spent twelve years in consumer PR, and I watched the same thing happen with comms hires constantly. A client would ask for a "senior account director" when what they needed was somebody to stop a founder going off-message on Radio 4. Different person entirely.
How to tell it's worked: you can explain the role in two sentences to someone outside the business, and they'd guess roughly what the person does on a Tuesday.
Beyond Tick Boxes: Diversity Recruitment Strategies That Actually Transform UK Workplaces
Master the Virtual Hot Seat: 7 Video Interview Techniques Recruiters Don't Tell You
AI Governance Careers Surge in 2026: Why This Role Will Define the Next Decade
2. Split the essentials from the wish list
This is the step everyone skips, and it's the one that decides the shortlist.
Take your requirements and sort them hard. Essential means you'd reject an otherwise excellent candidate without it. Everything else is a preference, and preferences belong in a separate column. Two or three essentials is normal. Seven is a fantasy.
Here's the objection, and it's a fair one: a longer spec filters out weaker applicants, so why not ask for everything? Sometimes that holds, in highly regulated or technical roles where a missing qualification really does end the conversation. But for most marketing roles, an overloaded spec filters out the wrong people. The candidates who tick all twelve boxes are often generalists who've skimmed every discipline. The one who's brilliant at lifecycle email and has never touched a CRM migration gets screened out before anyone sees them.
How to tell it's worked: show the list to a colleague and ask which line they'd drop first. If they can't answer, your essentials are properly tight.
3. Put a number on the salary and the flexibility
Give the recruiter a real range, not "competitive". And say whether it moves. If you'd stretch £8,000 for the right person, say so now. Hiding that costs you the best candidate, who'll quietly price themselves out of your range at first call.
Same goes for hybrid arrangements and location. Be specific about office days. Marketing talent is choosy about this, and a recruiter who has to guess will guess wrong.
How to tell it's worked: the recruiter never has to ask "is there any wiggle room?" in week two.
4. Brief the recruiter live, not by email
Send the written spec, then talk it through for twenty minutes. A good recruiter will push back, and you want that. If yours nods along to everything, find another one.
Give them three things the spec can't carry: why the last person left (or why the role is new), who the best team member is and what makes them good, and one or two companies you'd happily see candidates from. Those hints do more than any bullet list. For more on using an agency well, there's a useful overview of transparent recruitment pricing before you sign terms.
How to tell it's worked: the recruiter repeats the role back to you in their own words and gets it right.
5. Agree what a shortlist looks like
Decide up front how many CVs, by when, and what each one must come with. Three to five strong candidates beats fifteen maybes, every time. Ask for a line on why each person fits against your essentials, not a generic pitch.
And agree how you'll give feedback. Same-day, with reasons. A recruiter who hears "not quite right" three times learns nothing. One who hears "strong on brand, no performance experience" recalibrates within a day. The Equality Act 2010 applies to how you screen, so keep your reasons tied to the essentials, not to hunches about fit.
How to tell it's worked: your second shortlist is visibly better than your first.
If a step goes wrong
Shortlist full of the wrong seniority? Your essentials were probably vague on scope, so go back to step one and rewrite what the person owns. Plenty of strong CVs but nobody you'd hire? The wish list leaked into the essentials, so cut it again. Too few candidates? Check your salary against the market and ask the recruiter plainly whether the range or the location is the blocker.
If two shortlists in a row miss, change the brief before you change the agency. Is the role you've described actually the role you need?
For a wider view of how hiring teams are working with recruiters now, OHUB's insights are worth a read, and the CIPD publishes sensible guidance on recruitment practice if you're building a process from scratch.

