'What I wish I'd known'
Red flags I missed when hiring my team member
What I wish I had known before making my first hire is that enthusiasm cannot make up for misalignment. Making your hire is one of the most exciting and nerve-wracking moments in building a business.
You are finally moving from doing everything yourself to leading a team. Because you are so eager to offload work and get back to growing the business it is easy to overlook warning signs during the interview process.
Looking back at my hiring experience I realized the missteps didn’t happen during onboarding. They happened before I even sent the offer letter. Here are the biggest red flags I missed—. What I look for now.
Beyond Tick Boxes: Diversity Recruitment Strategies That Actually Transform UK Workplaces
Master the Virtual Hot Seat: 7 Video Interview Techniques Recruiters Don't Tell You
AI Governance Careers Surge in 2026: Why This Role Will Define the Next Decade
Hiring for urgency over alignment
1. Hiring for urgency of alignment
When you are drowning in work anyone who seems capable feels like a lifesaver. I rushed my hire because I needed immediate relief, which caused me to prioritize availability over long-term fit.
The Lesson: Never hire out of desperation. Taking a two weeks to find the right person saves months of retraining, miscommunication and turnover later.
Accountability matters in early hires
2. Ignoring answers about past challenges
During the interview I asked about a time a project went wrong. The candidate gave an answer that placed all the blame on former managers and unclear instructions without mentioning what they did to solve the problem.
At the time I brushed it off as them having had a previous employer.
The Lesson: Early team members need ownership. Look for candidates who take accountability for mistakes and show resourcefulness when things aren’t clearly mapped out.
Curiosity reveals genuine commitment
3. Overlooking a lack of curiosity about the business
My first hire answered every question well. Barely asked any questions about our customers, goals or daily workflows.
I assumed they were just nervous or respectful of my time. In reality they were looking for a task list than a mission to contribute to.
The Lesson: Your first employees set the tone. Great early hires are naturally curious—they ask questions about how the business works and how their role drives results.
Test projects beat interviews
4. Skipping a test project
I relied heavily on a strong resume and a great conversation. Because we clicked personally I assumed their day-to-day execution would match their interview performance.
Once they started it became clear that our communication styles and work standards were out of sync.
The Lesson: Always include a paid trial project or realistic scenario exercise. Seeing how someone actually approaches a problem reveals more than an interview ever will.
5. Avoiding conversations about expectations
Because I wanted to seem like a flexible modern leader I kept expectations loose. When small issues popped up in the few weeks—like missed deadlines or uncommunicated delays—I let them slide instead of addressing them directly.
Those small habits quickly became the standard.
The Lesson: Clarity is kindness. Define what success looks like in the 30, 60 and 90 days, before day one and give honest feedback early.
Final thoughts
Making a hiring mistake doesn’t mean you are a leader. It is simply part of learning how to build a team. Every misstep teaches you how to define your standards clearly ask better questions and trust your instincts when something feels off.