If you're weighing a secure offer against an early-stage startup, this is for you. By the end you'll have a written answer to the question, built from your own numbers and the founders' replies, not from a gut feeling at 2am. It's aimed at early-career people and anyone changing direction, and it assumes you've got both offers (or at least one offer and one serious conversation) in front of you.
Short version of my view: a startup is the right call when you can survive the downside and the role teaches you something the stable job can't. Plenty of people fail the first test and never realise it.
1. Write down what you can afford to lose
Start with money, because nothing else matters if you can't pay rent in month seven. Work out your monthly outgoings (rent, bills, loan repayments, travel, the lot) and then count how many months of those you could cover from savings if the salary stopped. Three months is thin. Six is comfortable.
You've done this step properly when you can say a number out loud: "I can cover X months with no income." If you can't say it, you haven't finished. Check your actual outgoings rather than guessing at them.
If you're a graduate living at home, your floor is lower and the maths favours risk. If you've got a mortgage or dependants, it doesn't, and that's not cowardice. It's arithmetic.
Beyond Tick Boxes: Diversity Recruitment Strategies That Actually Transform UK Workplaces
Master the Virtual Hot Seat: 7 Video Interview Techniques Recruiters Don't Tell You
AI Governance Careers Surge in 2026: Why This Role Will Define the Next Decade
2. Compare the two offers on the same page
Put both jobs side by side in a simple table: base salary, pension contribution, holiday, notice period, sick pay, equity, and what the role will actually have you doing in year one. Startups often pay below market on base and make up the gap with share options, which brings you to the awkward bit.
Treat equity as a lottery ticket you were given for free. It might be worth something. Most of the time it's worth nothing, and you should price it at roughly zero when you do your sums. If the base salary only works if the options pay out, the offer doesn't work.
You've done this step properly when the stable job and the startup each have a column of facts, with no adjectives in it.
3. Ask the founders the questions that matter
Most candidates ask about culture and the product vision. Fine, but those answers are free for founders to give. Ask about money and runway instead. Here's wording you can lift straight into an email or a call:
"Could you tell me how much runway the company has at the current burn rate, and when you expect to raise the next round?"
"Who are the current investors, and is this role funded by the money already in the bank?"
"If the next raise slips by six months, what happens to the team and to my role?"
A good founder answers these without flinching, and a decent one will respect you for asking. If you get vagueness, defensiveness, or a long speech about the mission, you've learned something useful. Also ask who you'd report to, and what that person did before. A first-time manager with no one above them is a different proposition from a seasoned operator.
It's worked when you can state the runway in months and name who's paying for your salary.
4. Check the company, not just the pitch
Look the company up on Companies House and read the filed accounts and the list of directors. It takes ten minutes. Small companies often file abridged accounts, so you won't see everything, but you can see whether it's been trading, whether directors have come and gone, and whether there are charges registered against it.
Then read the company's own paper trail. Look at the team on LinkedIn, how long people have stayed, and whether anyone senior has left recently. Ask to speak to someone who isn't a founder. A request like "Would it be possible to have a quick chat with someone on the team about what a normal week looks like?" is entirely reasonable, and the reaction tells you plenty.
If you're switching careers rather than starting out, add one more check: can the startup actually teach you the new thing, or are you the only person there who's meant to know it?
5. Ask what you'd learn that the stable job can't offer
This is the step people skip, and it's the one that decides whether the risk is worth taking. A stable job at an established employer usually gives you structure, training, a recognisable name on your CV and a manager whose job includes developing you. A startup gives you breadth, speed and responsibility you wouldn't be trusted with elsewhere.
I'd argue the breadth is overrated for some people and gold for others. If you're early-career and need someone to show you how good work is done, a startup with no senior mentor can leave you with a year of confident bad habits. If you already know the fundamentals and you're itching to own something, the stable job may bore you rigid.
Write two sentences: what I'd learn at the startup, and what I'd learn at the stable job. If the first one is vague, that's your answer.
For a closer look at what the first months tend to involve, this piece on working at an early stage startup is worth reading before you sign.
6. Plan your way back before you jump
Startups fail, and often for reasons that have nothing to do with you. So ask yourself what happens if this one folds in eighteen months. Could you get a job at the stable employer, or one like it? Would the startup on your CV help or hinder?
In my experience, employers read a failed startup stint far more kindly than candidates fear, as long as you can describe what you built and what you owned. A CV line like this does the job: "Joined as one of the first five hires; set up the onboarding process and handled the first 40 customer accounts." Specifics beat adjectives every time.
Keep your CV current while you're there. Don't wait for the bad news to update it. If you want to see what's out there as a fallback, you can browse current roles on OHUB and keep a sense of what the market looks like for your skills.
The step has worked when you can name two or three employers who'd plausibly hire you if the startup collapsed.
7. Make the decision, then negotiate
By now you've got a savings figure, a side by side comparison, the founders' answers on runway, a view on what you'd learn, and a way back. Look at them together. If the startup passes on all five, say yes. If it fails on the money step, say no or negotiate. If it's close, push for a better base, a clear review date at six months, or a written description of your responsibilities.
A line you can use: "I'm keen on the role. To make the move work financially, I'd need the base to be X. Is there flexibility there, or could we agree a review at six months?" Founders hear versions of this constantly. Asking won't cost you the offer if you ask politely.
If you want a sharper read on how to handle that conversation, the employers section on OHUB shows how hiring teams think about offers, which helps you anticipate their position.
The decision is made when you've sent your answer and you don't need to check your phone every ten minutes.
If a step goes wrong
If the founders dodge the runway question, treat that as a no until proven otherwise. You can ask once more in writing, which gives them time to answer properly. If the second answer is still woolly, walk.
If your savings number is lower than you'd like, you don't have to refuse the startup outright. Ask for a higher base, or a start date a couple of months later so you can build a buffer. Both are reasonable requests.
If the stable employer won't hold the offer while you decide, ask for a few extra days, and say why. If they won't give you any, that tells you something about how they'd treat you as an employee. If they still refuse, decide on what's in front of you, not on what you fear you'll miss.
And if you've done all seven steps and you're still split down the middle, the numbers are probably telling you the two options are equal. Pick the one you'd regret not trying.
This week, do step one: open a spreadsheet and write down your monthly outgoings and your savings. Ten minutes. Everything else depends on it.