The death of the traditional media buying role has been greatly exaggerated. I've been watching this space for over a decade now, and I'm still getting frantic calls from clients desperate to find that unicorn who can handle both the platform technicalities and the strategic thinking required in today's market.
The truth? Most recruitment processes for media buyers are stuck in 2020. Agencies assess for skills that were relevant when Meta was still just Facebook and TikTok was for teenagers dancing in their bedrooms.
Right, let me share what I'm actually seeing on the ground.
Media Buying Has Fundamentally Changed
Hiring managers - especially the older ones - are still looking for people who can build a decent media plan and negotiate rates. But that's barely half the job now.
The real value of today's media buyers lies in their ability to navigate the fragmented platform universe while keeping pace with increasingly sophisticated automation tools. After placing dozens of specialists across London agencies last quarter alone, I've noticed that the difference between an average media buyer and an exceptional one isn't platform knowledge. It's the ability to interrogate platform data without getting bamboozled by the shiny metrics that platforms love to showcase.
One agency head I spoke with last week put it brilliantly: "We don't need button-pushers anymore. We need translators who can speak both client language and algorithm language."
Beyond Tick Boxes: Diversity Recruitment Strategies That Actually Transform UK Workplaces
Master the Virtual Hot Seat: 7 Video Interview Techniques Recruiters Don't Tell You
AI Governance Careers Surge in 2026: Why This Role Will Define the Next Decade
Where Traditional Recruitment Fails
Look at most media buyer job descriptions and you'll spot the problem immediately. They're asking for:
- X years of experience (as if time served equals competence)
- Platform certifications (which everyone has)
- Client management skills (vague and unmeasurable)
None of this tells you whether someone can actually deliver results in the current landscape, where first-party data strategies and privacy-first targeting have completely rewritten the playbook.
There's also a bizarre disconnect between what hiring managers say they want (strategic thinkers) and what they actually test for (technical platform knowledge). I've sat through enough interviews to know that most assessment processes are wildly outdated.
Better Assessment Frameworks
The Technical-Strategic Balance
Instead of the standard "walk me through your experience" interview, structure your assessment around these three pillars:
-
Automation Comprehension - Can they distinguish between what should be automated and what requires human oversight? Ask them to critique an existing automated buying strategy. The best candidates will immediately identify where the machines are making false assumptions.
-
Data Interpretation - Present them with a messy, real-world campaign dashboard (not the cleaned-up case studies they've prepared). Watch how they navigate ambiguity and contradictory metrics.
-
Privacy-First Thinking - The UK's enforcement of existing data regulations has tightened considerably this year. Can they build effective targeting strategies within these constraints?
Boris at a major high street retailer recently shared how they've completely overhauled their interview process - candidates now spend 90 minutes working through an actual campaign problem rather than talking through their CV. The difference in quality of hire has been stark.
Red Flags vs. Green Lights
Red Flags
- They can't explain attribution beyond the platform's reporting
- Their examples all feature enormous budgets (they may struggle with efficiency)
- They talk about "best practices" without questioning them
- They can't articulate how they'd adapt to a sudden platform algorithm change
Green Lights
- They can translate complex media metrics into business outcomes
- They bring up measurement limitations unprompted
- They ask questions about your first-party data capabilities
- They discuss creative testing frameworks alongside media strategies
The strongest media buyers I've placed this year all share one trait: intellectual honesty about what actually drives performance. They're comfortable saying "we don't know for certain" and then designing tests to find out.
2026 Compensation & Market Realities
Salary expectations for experienced media buying talent reflect a tight candidate market, requiring agencies to align their pay bands with modern industry benchmarks.
Current market benchmarks: Mid-Level London Media Buyers: Base salaries range from £55,000 to £75,000+ depending on strategic breadth.
Retail Media Specialists: Command an additional 15% to 20% salary premium due to high demand and acute talent shortages. Hiring Friction: Agencies offering compensation based on outdated pay bands experience higher candidate drop-off and extended vacancy times.
Where to Find Them
Here's the frustrating part. The best media buyers rarely appear on job boards. Their LinkedIn profiles aren't optimised for recruiters because they're being approached constantly already.
Focusing your search strategy on three areas yields better results:
-
Industry Networks - Events like MAD//Fest and the Campaign Media Summit have returned to in-person formats, making them valuable hunting grounds
-
Agency Transitions - Identify agencies going through restructures or client losses
-
Platform Talent - Many platforms have downsized their agency support teams, releasing talented individuals with deep platform knowledge
And yes, specialist headhunters can help, particularly those with access to passive candidates who aren't actively job hunting but might be open to the right opportunity.
The Interview Questions That Actually Work
Forget "tell me about yourself" and try these instead:
- "What's a popular media buying best practice you think is actually wrong?"
- "How would you explain incrementality testing to a CEO who's never heard of it?"
- "When have you recommended spending less money, not more?"
- "What's your process when a campaign is underperforming midway through?"
What you're looking for isn't perfect answers, but thought processes that reveal how they approach problems. The strongest candidates will answer with nuance, not certainty.
Retention: The Part Everyone Forgets
Hiring great media buyers is difficult enough. Keeping them is another challenge entirely.
I've watched countless agencies invest months in recruitment only to lose their new hires within a year because they failed to provide:
- Regular exposure to strategy discussions beyond their day-to-day
- Clear progression paths that don't force them into people management
- Training budgets that keep pace with platform changes
- Access to actual business results (not just media metrics)
The agencies with the highest retention rates have created development frameworks specifically for specialists, rather than forcing them into generalist career paths.
Building Long-Term Media Buying Capability
The cleverest agencies aren't just hiring for today's needs. They're building training pipelines and knowledge sharing systems that reduce their dependency on external recruitment.
Consider implementing:
- Cross-discipline rotation programmes
- Client-facing opportunities for junior buyers
- Internal certification processes
- Mentorship structures that pair technical experts with strategic thinkers
One independent agency I work with has created a remarkable 12-month development programme that's become their secret weapon for both attraction and retention. They barely need to recruit externally anymore.
At some point, we need to acknowledge that the talent shortage in media buying isn't going away. Building your own talent might be the only sustainable solution.
Final Thoughts
Hiring great media buyers in 2026 requires completely rethinking what the role actually entails. The old job descriptions, interview processes, and assessment frameworks just don't cut it anymore.
What separates the agencies who consistently hire well from those constantly struggling with vacancies isn't budget - it's their understanding of how the role has evolved and their willingness to adapt their recruitment processes accordingly.
And please, for the love of God, stop asking candidates to prepare case studies on campaigns they've already done. Ask them to solve problems they haven't seen before. That's what the job actually requires.
