Use this checklist before your first round of one-to-ones, and again after about a month, when the cracks start to show. It's built for new managers with a small team and no one handing them a template. Most of it takes minutes. The bits that look optional usually aren't.
Before the first meeting
-
Tell the person what the meeting is for. Send a short note a few days ahead. Something like: "I'd like us to have 30 minutes every fortnight. It's your time, not a status update. Bring whatever's on your mind." Without that, people assume it's an assessment and arrive guarded.
-
Pick a slot you won't move. A one-to-one that gets bumped for a client call teaches your team exactly where they rank. Fortnightly and kept beats weekly and cancelled.
-
Choose the room. A glass-walled meeting pod in an open-plan office is a poor place for a conversation about workload or a difficult colleague. Walk and talk, a quiet room, or a video call from somewhere private all work better.
-
Read the last few weeks of their work. Skim the project tracker, recent emails, anything they've shipped. You'll ask better questions and you won't waste their time making them brief you.
Beyond Tick Boxes: Diversity Recruitment Strategies That Actually Transform UK Workplaces
Master the Virtual Hot Seat: 7 Video Interview Techniques Recruiters Don't Tell You
AI Governance Careers Surge in 2026: Why This Role Will Define the Next Decade
Setting up a simple structure
-
Keep a shared running document. One page per person, in whatever tool you already use. Both of you add to it. It stops the meeting resetting to zero every time, and it gives you evidence when appraisal season arrives.
-
Split the time roughly in half. Their agenda first, yours second. New managers tend to flip this because they've got things to say. Resist it. If you do all the talking, you'll learn nothing.
-
Have three standing questions. "What's going well?", "What's getting in your way?" and "What would you change if it were up to you?" cover most ground. Add one about development every other meeting, such as "What do you want to be doing more of in a year?"
During the meeting
-
Ask, then wait. Count to five in your head after a question. The pause feels awkward for you and useful for them. The real answer is often the second one.
-
Write down actions that are yours. If you say "I'll look into the training budget", it goes in the document with a date. Dropping your own promises does more damage to trust than almost any other early mistake.
-
Separate feedback from the weekly grind. Small corrections can live here. A serious performance concern shouldn't arrive as a surprise in a routine catch-up. If it's big enough to worry you, it's big enough for its own conversation, and your HR team will have a process for it (the CIPD publishes plenty of general guidance on handling this well).
If your situation is different
-
If you're managing former peers: name it once, lightly. "This is a bit odd for both of us, so tell me if I get something wrong." Then carry on. Pretending nothing has changed is worse.
-
If someone is more senior or experienced than you: ask what support looks like for them. Don't coach them on their own craft. Your job is removing obstacles and giving context.
-
If your team is remote or hybrid: keep the cameras question flexible and don't let the meeting drift into logistics. People working from home often have fewer chances to raise small worries.
After the meeting
-
Spend five minutes tidying your notes. Capture actions and anything you'd forget. Someone who mentioned a sick parent or a house move will notice if you remember, and notice more if you don't.
-
Look back after a month. Are you doing most of the talking? Are the same issues reappearing? Ask your team directly what to change. If you'd like to see how other managers describe their approach when they interview for leadership roles, the OHUB insights hub is a reasonable place to start, and current openings show what employers expect from new team leads.
The item most people skip
Ask for feedback on the meetings themselves. Nearly every new manager skips it, because it feels exposed. Try this line at the end of your third one-to-one: "Is this a good use of your time? What should I do differently?" Most people will say it's fine. A few will tell you something you needed to hear, and you'll only get that if you ask.
This week: put your first (or next) round of one-to-ones in the diary, send the "what this is for" note, and open one shared document per person.